Frustrating, But Worth It: "A Court of Thorns and Roses"

To begin, this is by no means a "YA" novel. I am surprised that the publishers would market it as such. While I am not offended by the content as I am an adult, I am frustrated because I almost had my 13 year old little sister read it before me and she is definitely not old enough for what occurs here.

I'm OK with novels like Graceling or The Blue Sword or even Fault in Our Stars that do contain sexual scenes and believe they are appropriate and healthy for a young audience. I say this to illustrate that my opinion is not based on an exaggerated sense of prudery.

BE WARNED: This book contains fairly explicit sexual scenes. Not extensive, but enough that this novel is actually New Adult.

That aside, I adore this book! I have a long held love affair with fractured fairytales and am forever looking to discover a new twist on one of my favorites. Everything from the name Feyre to the complications that arise with Rhys fit into the world that Sarah J Maas creates.

This book has a natural flow, but variation and change. One of my least favorite characters is the person I admire most by the end of the book. I love the reality that is presented about relationships and the rejection of the idea that every being that comes into contact with the leading lady has to fall in love with her.

The descriptions are fresh without feeling forced and the abstraction that is the world of Fae is expressed without me feeling like I didn't understand anything.

I simply love this book. I do recommend that people read and enjoy this novel. However, I will restate the earlier warning that this book should not be considered YA.

On another note, other versions of this fairytale (that happen to be two of my all time favorite books) are East by Edith Pattou and Sun and Moon, Ice and Snow by Jessica Day George. They follow the story a bit more traditionally, but they are also firmly YA for those unprepared for the content of this novel.

Comments

Review of Roar by Cora Carmack

I had many fellow book-lovers recommend Roar , so I saved it for a relaxing road-trip, anticipating an enjoyable read. And that is what I got... for the most part. First, this book is definitely a romance. It hits you over the head with intense physical emotions in the first few pages and it never leaves. Whether it's a villain or a random soldier she vaguely recognizes, Aurora (or Roar), can sense the myriad of men who are attracted to her. Apparently none of them are unattractive or boorish, it just so happens that every man she meets wants something more from her. I found this a bit ridiculous. The attraction that supposedly every man has for her seems forced and makes her less sincere. I don't care how attractive you are supposed to be, most girls I know, models and nerds alike, are more likely to assume someone isn't attracted to them than is. It's a sad truth, but we aren't built like that. Also, she does not have the fiercely confident and experience...

The Boy in the Striped Pajamas

OK, before anyone judges my harsh review of this much beloved book, I have to defend my two star review. My first complaint is the voice. I have grown up in a family of 8 children, I have many cousins with young children whom I am close to, I babysit, and I am generally very familiar with children. This book felt like it was going between the voice of a two and twenty year old. That took away from the story to me. I am also well travelled and have German family. The Holocaust has long fascinated me and I still have memories of visiting concentration camps at a young age and being physically ill over what I learned and saw. One of my favorite movies is La Vita é Bella (please watch it). This book did not line up with a lot of the history of WWII that I have read. Also, the extreme ignorance of the main character is unbelievable. The concept is good and I feel like putting children in the context of some of the world's greatest tragedies is a powerful tool, I just felt ...

The Poets Laureate Anthology

I hope at least one person who stumbles across this blog shares my love for poetry. This book is a perfect collection of the greatest works of the American Poet Laureates from 1937-2010. Yes, it is full of brilliance and I can always find a poem to fit my mood. P.S. On a shallow side note, the cover looks cute on any shelf!

Living Literarily

Search This Blog